TODAY, IN UNANSWERABLE QUESTIONS

 

April 15
cloudy

I asked some fellow playwrights for their responses to the following quotation.

“I have often said, and oftener think, that this world is a comedy to those that think, a tragedy to those that feel.” – Horace Walpole

Do you think life is a comedy or a tragedy? 

Hansol Jung:

Life’s a comedy if you’re watching.
Tragedy if no one’s watching, or everyone’s watching but inconsequential to the solving of the problem.
If you can achieve the genius craft of watching yourself through life, it seems you could laugh yourself from cradle to grave
but as for me I experience most events in life as a series of small secret triumphs and failures in tragedies that I tend to morph into comedies in hindsight, because such earnestness is shameful after time puts a distance between the hero me and the now me, and lets me watch.

Milo Cramer:

I think life is clearly a TRAGEDY
if you think it’s a comedy OK cool but that’s insane
have you left the hot tub you were born in

perhaps life = a tragedy aspiring to comedy (?)
maybe comedy and tragedy are not helpful terms

Emily Zemba:

I think life is a comedy! If it isn’t comedy, then why is it so strange? And so fleeting? And so filled with frightening coincidences and funny-looking dogs?
I think one of the greatest things about being human, is our ability to employ critical thinking, and to analyze life’s most intense events and mysteries from a place of intellectual distance. I do wonder what would happen if I allowed myself to feel, and only feel, deeply, with every part of my being, through all life’s twists and dark turns and surprises — would the “tragedy of it all” sink in then?
Perhaps.

Ray Yamanouchi:

Life – A Play

Characters:
Comedy
Tragedy

COMEDY:
Why are you such an asshole?

TRAGEDY:
Lighten up.

End of Play.

Jacob Perkins:

Walpole’s quote reminds me of a similar saying: “In music, when you’re happy, you listen to the beats.  When you’re sad, you listen to the lyrics.” I think music functions best when the beats feed the lyrics and vice versa, so similarly, life is most interesting when it blends comedy and tragedy.  Can’t have one without the other.

 


Mary Cassatt’s “The Cup of Tea,” in which two women ponder exactly this question.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *